Simplifying dietary advice
Food can be split into two broad categories:
(1) Green vegetables and fruit which
nutritionists recommended we have a minimum daily intake of. And
(2) Foodstuffs high in fats, sugar and
salt where we should moderate our daily
intake.
These recommendations could be
quantified in two numbers called say Health Units and
Moderation Units, with a healthy
adult male diet being one that was based
on a minimum of 10 Health Units and a maximum of 10
Moderation Units. The food industry would
be encouraged to label its products to advise purchasers on their
Health and Moderation Unit ratings.
The 10 health units would replace the current
rather vague advice that for a healthy diet people should eat five
portions of fresh fruit and vegetables each day.
Calculation of Moderation Units
If you are in a hurry, you may wish to skip
the calculations in this section and move straight on to
What does
this mean to the consumer?
below.
Here are some simple examples of how the new system could work,
based on MAFF guidelines for "average" adult diets published in
1996.
Recommended maximum daily intake
Food type Male
Female
Saturated fats 30 g
20 g
Other fats 65 g
50 g
Sugars 70 g
50 g
Salt
2.5 g 2.0 g
Let's assume that dieticians decide to
aggregate the adult male intake together
as 10 Moderation Units
with 2 units being allocated to saturated fats, 2 units for other
fats and 3 units each for sugars and salt. The recommended adult
male intake of these foods can then be reworked as follows:
In grams
In Mod. Units
Giving grams in one unit
Saturated fats 30 g
2
15
Other fats 65 g
2
32.5
Sugars 70 g
3
23.3
Salt 2.5 g
3
0.83
Plugging these values for the number of grams/unit into the
recommended female intake gives the following:
In grams
In Moderation
Units
Saturated fats 20 g
1.33
Other fats 50 g
1.54
Sugars 50 g
2.15
Salt 2.0
g 0.83
Total 7.4 Moderation Units
What does
this mean to the consumer?
If the current dietary advice for men on eating fats, sugars
and salt is summed up in one number as, “Don’t eat more than
10 Moderation Units”, then the corresponding recommendation for
women works out at 7.4 Moderation Units. In a similar way to that
shown above, dieticians can work out the recommended intake for
children and also fine tune the numbers to take into account body
type and lifestyle. All the consumer needs to remember is one simple
number, which sums up their personal moderate eating requirements.
Consumers also need to be aware of the
importance of eating a balanced diet. With reference to the
Moderation Units,
this information could be supplied on products in the form of a pie
chart, showing the balance of fats, sugars and salt
in the product.
Examples:
Taking the nutritional information supplied on some popular snack
foods, the Moderation Unit
information could be presented as:
Kelloggs
Nutri Grain Bar
2.2
Moderation Units
Pot
of Pot Noodles
1.9
Moderation Units
Small tin
of Pringles crisps
2.3
Moderation Units
8
ounce bag of wine gums
2.7 Moderation Units
Labelling of packaged meals & food on
restaurant menus A simple label such as 2.5M/1.3H could
be added to an item on a menu worth 2.5 Moderation Units and 1.3
Health Units. Customers wanting to eat well but also look after
their health would tend to choose items having low Moderation Unit
and high Health Unit values.
Discussion It will only require a small percentage of
consumers to change their brand loyalty in favour
of higher Health Unit, lower
Moderation Unit foods, to shift the
profitability into healthy foods. So market forces will oblige
manufacturers to compete in offering
healthier products to the benefit of us
all, including those of us who don't bother to read the product
labels.
Doing the sums The calculations required to produce the pie
charts and Health and Moderation
Unit values of recipes could be done very
quickly using a computer. Anyone creating a new food product for
commercial production or for publication as a recipe would simply
need to enter a few facts about the ingredients used and the cooking
method to generate the unit values per portion.
Future proofing dietary education
The healthy eating rules based on a minimum of 10 Health
Units and a maximum of 10 Moderation Units
for an adult male could be maintained over time, even if the
assumptions concerning what constitutes a healthy
diet have to be changed as dietary knowledge improves.
The underlying calculations may change, but the
numbers displayed on products can maintain the same format.
This means that the 10/10 healthy eating rules learned by today's
children will still be valid when they become parents and grand
parents.