VOTE FOR YOUR BEST & WORST DUNDEE TEAMS OVER THE LAST 25 YEARS
ALL TEAMS TO BE 4-4-2


SUBMIT TEAMS BY Email to jmbdarkblues@lineone.net



As voting stands at the moment the Best Dundee player over the last 25 years is tied between TOMMY COYNE (80's Version) and TOSH McKINLAY, while the worst player is beyond doubt VINCE MENNIE.

If you disagree with the votes, the only way it can be changed is by submitting your own choices. The last 3 teams submitted has seen Neil McCann come into the team at the expense of Robert Connor.

The BEST and WORST teams as voting stands are as follows:

BEST WORST
1 RAB DOUGLAS 1 ALAN BLAIR
2 TOSH McKINLAY 2 MIKE TEASDALE
3 JIM DUFFY 3 GARY PATTERSON
4 CAMMY FRASER 4 WES SAUNDERS
5 STUART McKIMMIE 5 ARTHUR ALBISTON
6 JOHN BROWN 6 VINCE MENNIE
7 DARIUSZ ADAMCZUK 7 STUART BEEDIE
8 NEIL MCCANN 8 ANDY KIWOMYA
9 MORTON WIEGHORST 9 ALBERT CRAIG
10 TOMMY COYNE 10 ROSS JACK
11 KEITH WRIGHT 11 WALKER McCALL
SUBSTITUTES SUBSTITUTES
GK BOBBY GEDDES GK BILLY THOMSON
12 DUSAN VRTO 12 COLIN HARRIS
14 BILLY DODDS 14 COLIN WEST
15 BRIAN IRVINE 15 COLIN HENDRY
16 ROBERT CONNOR 16 IVO DEN BIEMAN

Submitted by: DAVID THOMPSON
BEST

Robert Douglas
Stewart McKimmie, Jim Duffy, Barry Smith, Tosh McKinlay
Iain Anderson John Brown Cammy Fraser Neil McCann
Tommy Coyne Keith Wright

WORST

Alan Blair
John McQuillan Peter Millar Iain MacDonald Lee Maddison
Peter Mackie Vince Mennie Albert Kidd Kevin Magee
Colin Harris Colin Hendry

Submitted by: GAV (ARAB HATER)
BEST

Robert Douglas
Dariusz Adamczuk, Ian Ure, Tosh McKinlay, Morten Wieghorst
Iain Anderson, Alan Gilzean, Neil McCann, Billy Dodds
Luna, Tommy Coyne

WORST

Bobby Geddes
Peter Miller, Bobby Glennie, Stephane Pounwatchey, Wes Saunders,
Andy Kiwomya, Stuart Beedie, Hugh Robertson, Craig Brown
Eddie Annand, Tommy Coyne

Submitted by: SCOTT QUINN
BEST

Robert Douglas
Alan Dinnie Willie Jamieson Jim Duffy Tosh McKinlay
Morten Weighorst John Brown Bobby Connor Neil McCann
Billy Dodds Tommy Coyne(mark 1)

WORST

Alan Blair
Kevin Bain Lionel David Mark Craib Arthur Albiston
Duncan Campbell Vince Mennie Andy Geddes Andy Kiwomya
Colin Harris Ross Jack

Submitted by: HEATHER ADAM
BEST

Robert Douglas
Tosh McKinlay, Jim Duffy, Barry Smith, Stewart McKimmie
Dariusz Adamczuk, John Brown, Gordon Strachan, Morton Wieghorst
Tommy Coyne, Keith Wright

WORST

Alan Blair
Miller, Wes Saunders, Kevin Bain, Stuart Beedie
Jim McInally, Vince Mennie, Colin West, Ross Jack
Eddie Annand, Walker McCall

Submitted by: MICHAEL COLGAN
BEST

Robert Douglas
Dariuz Adamczuk, Barry Smith, Jim Duffy, Rab Shannon
Iain Anderson, Morton Weighorst, Chic Charnely, Neil McCann
Tommy Coyne, Keith Wright

WORST

Paul Mathers
Craig Tully, Gary Patterson, Gordon Hunter, Mike Teasdale
Paul Tosh, Ivo Den Beiman, Colin West , Andy Kiwomya
Paul Ritchie Gerry Bitton

Submitted by: JAMES DUNN
BEST

Robert Douglas
Stuart McKimmie, Tosh McKinlay, Barry Smith, Jim Duffy
Morton Wieghorst, John Brown, Gordon Strachan, Robert Conner
Tommy Coyne, Keith Wright

WORST

Colin Kelly
Stuart Forsyth, Gary Patterson, Jim Smith, Noel Blake
Mark Craib, Vince Mince, Ivo Den Bieman, Andy Kiwomya
Walker McCall, Ross Jack

Submitted by: GORDON WHITE
BEST

Robert Douglas
Dusan Vrto, Tosh McKinlay, Brian Irvine, Jim Duffy
Morton Wieghorst, John Brown, Darius Adamczuk, Neil McCann
Tommy Coyne, Billy Dodds

WORST

Jim Leighton
John Holt, Gary Patterson, Kevin Bain, Stuart Beedie
Darren Magee, Vince Mince, Ivo Den Bieman, Ian Angus
Alan Campbell, Paul Ritchie

Submitted by: IAIN SMALL
BEST

Bobby Geddes
Stuart McKimmie, Tosh McKinlay, Bobby Glennie, Jim Duffy
Bobby Connor, Bomber Brown, Darius Adamczuk, Neil McCann
Tommy Coyne, Iain Ferguson

WORST

Alan Blair
John Holt, Eric Schaedler, Wes Saunders, Stephane Pounwatchey
Dusan Vrto, Vince Mince, Eric Garcin, Ross Jack
Walker McCall, Colin Harris

Submitted by: FRASER MacDONALD
BEST
Robert Douglas
Dariusz Adamczuk, Jim Duffy, Dusan Vrto, Tosh McKinlay
Robert Connor, John Brown, Morten Wieghorst, Neil McCann
Tommy Coyne(80's), Keith Wright

Worst
Jim Leighton
Arthur Albiston, Wes Saunders, Garry Paterson, Mike Teasdale
Vince Mennie, Albert Craig, Alan Campbell, Colin West
Tommy Coyne (90s), Walker McCall

Submitted by JIM SCALLAN
BEST
Rab Douglas
Stuart McKimmie, Jim Duffy, Dusan Vrto, Tosh McKinlay
Cammy Fraser, John Brown, Gordon Strachan, Dariusz Adamczuk
Tommy Coyne, Keith Wright
WORST

Jim Leighton
Les Barr, Willie Jamieson, Gordon Hunter, Mark Craib
Vince Mennie, Stuart Beedie, Gordon McLeod, Albert Craig
Walker McCall, Colin West

Submitted by ?
John Arrol
Eric Shaedler, Jim McInally, John Brown, Bobby Ford,
Cammy Fraser, Billy Campbell, Jocky Scott, Jim Shirra,
Billy Pirie, John Duncan,

WORST
ALAN BLAIR
PETER MILLAR, MIKE TEASDALE, GARY PATTERSON, ARTHUR ALBISTON
VINCE MENNIE, STUART BEEDIE, COLIN WEST, ANDY KIWOMYA
COLIN HENDRY, COLIN HARRIS
Submitted by GRAEME DARE
BEST
Rab Douglas
Stuart McKimmie, Jim Duffy, Barry Smith, Tosh McKinlay
Morten Weighorst, John Brown, Bobby Connor, Iain Anderson
Billy Dodds, Keith Wright

WORST
Alan Blair
Leslie Barr, Iain MacDonald, Graeme MacFarlane, David Winnie
Vince Mennie, Billy Kirkwood, Colin West, Paul Tosh
Alan Campbell, Ross Jack
Submitted by NIALL McTAVISH
BEST
ROBERT DOUGLAS
STEPHEN FRAIL, JIM DUFFY, DUSAN VRTO, TOSH McKINLAY
MORTON WIEGHORST, CAMMY FRASER, JOHN BROWN, BOBBY CONNOR,
TOMMY COYNE, KEITH WRIGHT
WORST
ALAN BLAIR
CRAIG TULLY, WES SAUNDERS, GRAEME FORBES, ARTHUR ALBISTON
DUNCAN CAMPBELL, PETER MACKIE, GEORGE McGEACHIE, ANDY KIWOMYA
COLIN WEST, WALKER McCALL
Submitted by NIALL McTAVISH - team 2
BEST
BOBBY GEDDES
STEWART McKIMMIE, BRIAN IRVINE, STEWART FORSYTH, RAB SHANNON
IAIN FERGUSON, GORDON STRACHAN, DARIUSZ ADAMCZUK, NEIL McCANN
GRAHAM HARVEY, BILLY DODDS
WORST
BILLY THOMPSON
MIKE TEASDALE,GARY PATTERSON, GORDON CHISHOLM, LIONEL DAVID
IVO DEN BIEMAN, MAX CHRISTIE, ALLAN CAMPBELL, ALAN LAWRENCE
COLIN HARRIS, ROSS JACK
Submitted by STUART SINCLAIR
BEST
BOBBY GEDDES
DUSAN VRTO, JIM DUFFY, STUART FORSYTH, TOSH McKINLAY
MORTON WIEGHORST, GORDON STRACHAN, BOBBY CONNOR, DARIUSZ ADAMCZUK
GRAHAM HARVEY, TOMMY COYNE
WORST
TOM CARSON
WES SAUNDERS,GARY PATTERSON, GORDON CHISHOLM, JOHN HOLT
JIM McINALLY, STUART BEEDIE, ALBERT CRAIG, ANDY KIWOMYA
COLIN HENDRY, COLIN HARRIS
Submitted by RYAN IRELAND
BEST
STUART McKIMMIE, JIM DUFFY, BRIAN IRVINE, TOSH McKINLAY
MORTON WIEGHORST, CAMMY FRASER, CHIC CHARNLEY, JOHN BROWN,
TOMMY COYNE, IAIN FERGUSON
WORST
BILLY THOMPSON
JOHN HOLT, CRAIG TULLY, GREAME FORBES, KEVIN RATCLIFFE
IVO DEN BIEMAN, BILLY KIRKWOOD, MARCUS DAILLY, STUART BEEDIE
ROSS JACK, COLIN HENDRY
Submitted by GARY MUDIE
BEST
RAB DOUGLAS
BARRY SMITH, BRIAN IRVINE, DUSAN VRTO, TOSH McKINLAY
DARIUSZ ADAMCZUK, CAMMY FRASER, JOHN BROWN, NEIL McCANN
TOMMY COYNE, KEITH WRIGHT
WORST
ALAN BLAIR
ARTHUR ALBISTON,GARY PATTERSON, STUART BEEDIE, MIKE TEASDALE
VINCE MENNIE, MAX CHRISTIE, GRAEME FORBES, DUNCAN CAMPBELL
PAUL RITCHIE, WALKER McCALL
Submitted by EDO
BEST
RAB DOUGLAS
RAB SHANNON, BRIAN IRVINE, JIM DUFFY, TOSH McKINLAY
DARIUSZ ADAMCZUK, CAMMY FRASER, JOHN BROWN, NEIL McCANN
TOMMY COYNE, KEITH WRIGHT
WORST
BILLY THOMSON
BARRY SMITH(95/96), STEFAN POUNWATCHY, LIONEL DAVID, LEE MADDISON
VINCE MENNIE, MAX CHRISTIE, ERIC GARCIN, ALBERT CRAIG
OLE GUNNAR SKONNER*, PAUL TOSH

*NORWEGIAN TRIALIST WHO CAME ON AS A SUB IN 0-0 DRAW WITH CLYDEBANK AT BOGHEAD IN 1996
Submitted by: GRANT HILL
BEST
ROBERT DOUGLAS
DARIUSZ ADAMCZUK, BRIAN IRVINE, JIM DUFFY, TOSH McKINLAY
MORTON WEIGHORST, JOHN BROWN, ROBERT CONNOR, NEIL McCANN
TOMMY COYNE, BILLY DODDS

WORST
TOM CARSON
ARTHUR ALBISTON, WES SAUNDERS, CRAIG TULLY, JOHN HOLT
VINCE MENNIE, ALBERT CRAIG, DUNCAN CAMPBELL, ANDY KIWOMYA
WALKER McCALL, ROSS JACK
Submitted by: SCOTT KINNEAR
BEST
RAB DOUGLAS
STEWART McKIMMIE, JIM DUFFY, WES SAUNDERS, TOSH McKINLEY
DARIUSZ ADAMCZUK, JOHN BROWN, CAMMY FRASER, ROBERT CONNOR
BILLY DODDS, TOMMY COYNE

WORST
ALAN BLAIR
PETER MILLAR, MIKE TEASDALE, GARY PATTERSON, ARTHUR ALBISTON
VINCE MENNIE, STUART BEEDIE, COLIN WEST, ANDY KIWOMYA
COLIN HENDRY, COLIN HARRIS